So I have not written in awhile, delinquency on my part yes, yes. But take into consideration that I started my current job at Berkeley College in February and I am midway through my second full quarter. I've taught over 40 Info Lit classes that were fired off at me with near precision. All in all I might have this thing called information specialist, librarian. A drink here or two doesn't hurt either.
But there is so much to reflect on and so many question to ponder as I sit in the trenches of information literacy and educational technology. One question I don't hesitate to answer is whether information literacy when it comes down to college students is a "class question". While the mass media portrays the average American person as being connected, tuned-in, tweeting out, face-booking high school and college sweethearts, masses of young people go without computers, less the par internet service that can keep up with the Internet savvy.
By the time they do get to college, working class students, largely from Black or Latino backgrounds, need to learn not only information literacy but need to distinguish media literacy at the same time as they are trying improve poor writing and math skills. All products of the American school system.
A perfect example of this was when I gave a research session for a Feminist Philosophy class. After the class, which was great, a student wanted to know the appropriate citation format for sources she had found on the Internet. I showed her a leaflet (crib sheet I had created for the new MLA rules). She insisted she just needed to know how to cite Google. I responded to her that "Google is Not an Information Source" it's just your messenger you've sent to retrieve the information you 1. put in and 2. the information you wish to retrieve.
She looked at me with a black stare. What? "But I got it from Google?"
"No. You went to a website that contain the information that you wanted. Do you remember what website it was?"
"Yes. It was Google."
So on it went. Is it really hard for any person to think that if you put something into Google and you go the result that you retrieve the information from Google itself? I don't think so especially with the proliferation of the edition of "google" as a verb in our lexicon in the past 10 years. But would most people think of how to use it in a works cited page for research? I don't know but you have to wonder how students in their formative years are taught the different forms of media on the Internet and how you can cross from website to search engine to social media in a blink of an eye.
So is information literacy a question of class politics?
2 comments:
Hi Romel! Just found your blog and am enjoying it. This post brings up something I see every day. Sometimes in a class, I'll ask students what Google does, and it always takes a while to go from "gives you answers" or "finds information" to "finds websites" and a discussion about the fact that each website is an object created by a particular author with an agenda and point of view. I do think class is involved, given the fewer resources/imperative to center curricula around multiple-choice tests/higher number of inexperienced teachers/etc. in the schools that most of our students came from vs. schools in affluent areas (plus the greater resources of wealthy families to access out-of-school educational development)--but I also wonder if students of any class are being taught to critically analyze all the "sources" they find.
It feels like a huge part of what we librarians do (or at least what I want to do) is encourage students to look beyond what an article/site/book is saying and also consider who is saying it, how they're saying it, and why. But then we have so little time to try to nurture these critical habits of mind. And our students, juggling jobs, family responsibilities, and school, are often very understandably just focused on "finding three sources to cite" instead of deeply ruminating, reflecting on, and questioning what they read.
Anyway, thank you for blogging about these things!
Haurko! Since I'm getting back heavily into the blog. I just realized I never saw your great comment! Thank you for stopping by. I feel some of the issues this is even more important now!
In struggle,
romel
Post a Comment